A judge ruled that Britney Spears’ father, Jamie Spears, must sit down for a statement and present all documents that are being requested by the pop star’s team. The judge ordered that Spears’ father be produced in Los Angeles within the next 30 days.
Judge Brenda Penney ordered Spears’ father to produce all documents related to the electronic surveillance. The move is in the singer’s favor, and indicates that the court believes it has reason to investigate the shocking allegations that Jamie Spears hired a security firm that her daughter Was placed under surveillance with charges of stealing her phone and sabotaging her bedroom. Record his private conversation.
Variety . Other Movies-TV Shows
Prior to the judge’s ruling, Jamie Spears’ attorney, Alex Weingarten, asked the judge to give his team access to documents from Singer’s team to help prepare for his client’s statement. The hearing at the Los Angeles Superior Courthouse was heated with heated arguments between Weingarten and Starr’s attorney, Matthew Rosengart.
“It’s a statement. Not an ambush,” Weingarten argued in the courtroom, before Judge Penny ruled against his request to obtain documents before his client’s statement.
Wednesday’s hearing marked a major victory for the singer, who has been fighting against her father in an ongoing legal battle since her guardianship ended last year.
Spears was placed under court-ordered protection in 2008 by her father, who had served as her sole guardian for most of the 13 years. Spears’ father was suspended by court in September 2021, after more than a decade of fighting against the arrangement, and the guardianship was eventually terminated in November 2021. Despite the singer’s newfound independence, her legal team battles have been tumultuous with no resolution. Both sides.
After about two hours, the judge called for recess, as another proposal was on the table: whether the pop star would need to be ousted by her father’s team.
Last month, Jamie Spears filed a document request to depose her daughter in light of social media posts; Rosengart blasted the request, calling it “revenge” and “sham”.
Initially, during the hearing, the judge granted a provisional order denying Jamie Spears’ motion to depose Britney Spears. But after arguments from Weingarten, who said she would appeal the decision, Penney indicated she might move the case to a later hearing, but then took a brief break from the courtroom.
“You don’t sit next to the victim for the victim’s statement,” Rosengart argued in the courtroom, adding that sitting for a statement would be “re-traumatized” to the singer.
At one point, begging the judge to allow his team to depose the pop star, Weingarten said that “unfortunately” there are documents under seal and “court order” regarding electronic surveillance. “Based on what I know,” he said, “I suspect Ms. Spears will be a treasure trove of information.”
Weingarten said that if the judge decides that Britney Spears does not have to sit for a statement, while Jamie Spears’s ruling, her client will not have a “reasonable day in court.” He said he was being held to “different standards” than other parties in the case based on “unsubstantiated allegations”.
“I appreciate that trashing Jamie Spears is in vogue,” Weingarten told the judge “but she has rights… In this country, you’re innocent until proven guilty.”
Rosengart stood up and vehemently opposed Weingarten. “You don’t put the victim back in front of the victim. It’s wrong to do that,” Rosengart said. “That would be wrong, whether my client was Britney Spears or Jane Doe.”
“The mere statement is harassment,” Rosengart told the judge.
Rosengart has been fighting against Jamie Spears and the singer’s former business manager, Trai Star Sports & Entertainment, ever since she was retained by Spears in the summer of 2021. He accused the company of “stonewalling” its efforts to obtain information for its clients, refusing to cooperate and evading statements. Spears’ legal team said they are requesting the elder Spears to be ousted for nine months, and claimed that they had shelved those requests. On Wednesday, during the hearing, the judge moved in favor of Penny Starr, concluding that Jamie Spears had failed to appear for her statement.
Earlier this month, in blatant court documents, Rosengart claimed that her client’s father and Trai Starr, instead of seeking out her best interest, mutually exploited millions of Superstar’s hard-earned money to create conservatism and profit. were involved in, which they deny. (Try Star and its founder, Lou Taylor, served as Superstar’s business managers from 2008 to 2020, and the company was hired by Spears’ father around the time he placed her under a mentor. )
Rosengart claimed that Trai Star was directly involved in creating the stereotype and received at least $18 million. Tri Star’s lawyers refuted this, saying, “As all evidence abundantly makes clear, the guardianship was established on the recommendation of the legal advisor, not Tri Star, and approved by the Court for more than 12 years.”
Spears’ father and Trai Star have faced serious allegations from both the media and private investigators appointed by Rosengart’s firm. While the surveillance allegations have largely focused on Spears’ father and Black Box, the security team it was accused of hiring, Trai Star has been at the center of widespread claims of financial mismanagement.
A New York Times report alleged that Starr was under the supervision of a security team appointed by her father and Trai Starr was involved in monitoring the singer’s phone. At the time, a Trai Star lawyer told the Times, “These allegations are not true.” Earlier this month, Weingarten filed an affidavit on Jamie Spears’s behalf, denying any awareness of her adult daughter’s private bedroom being sabotaged or authorizing the pop star’s oversight. “I have been informed of the allegation made by Brittany’s attorney that a hearing aid or ‘bug’ was placed in her bedroom as a form of surveillance,” the announcement said. “This allegation is false.”
best of variety
Sign up for the Variety newsletter. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for the latest news.
Click here to read the full article.