Should Beyonce Have Told Kelis She Was Sampling Her Song?

Should Beyonce Have Told Kelis She Was Sampling Her Song?

In the past 48 hours, the only noise comparable to Beyhive’s buzz is coming from R&B singer Kelis, who is furious that Beyoncé sampled her 2003 song “Milkshake” without informing her. The sample appears in the song “Energy” from Beyoncé’s recently released album “Renaissance”; The officially credited writers and producers of “Milkshake” are the Neptunes, aka Pharrell Williams, and Chad Hugo, who are credited with most of Kelis’ early recordings.

In a long string of Instagram posts, Kelis writes, “This isn’t a collab it’s a steal. My mind is also blown because the level of disrespect and utter ignorance of all 3 parties involved is astonishing… I heard about it just like everyone else. Nothing is as it seems, some people in this business have no soul or integrity and have fooled everyone.”

Variety . Other Movies-TV Shows of

There’s a lot to unpack here on a professional, personal and macro level.

From a legal standpoint, two seasoned music-business lawyers point out Diversity It is possible but unlikely that Beyoncé’s team will need a contract to inform Kelis about the sample, even though she is the performing artist on “Milkshake”: she is neither work’s credited author (who that Williams and Hugo are) nor the copyright holder (Virgin Records, which is owned by Universal Music Group). Kelis acknowledged this in Friday’s Instagram video, where she says it should be “human decency” for Beyoncé to tell her she was using the song, though she said the situation was “really on Beyoncé’s”. Wasn’t about.” the issue there seems more personal: both had “Meet each other, we know each other, we have mutual friends. it’s not difficult. She can contact me, can’t she?”

However, the issues with Neptune go back more than 23 years. Kelis and the two were in the early stages of their careers when their first songs together were released in December of 1999: While Williams and Hugo were in their mid-20s and a single with lyrics by Ol’ Dirty Bastard, MC Light. There was a growing songwriter-production team. , SWV, Clipse and others, Kelis was just 20 years old. The three were close friends at that time. Kelis has previously stated that he feels he was not properly credited or compensated for his work with the two.

“I was told we were going to split 33/33/33 all over, which we didn’t,” she told the Guardian in 2020. She says that she “was lied to and deceived” by “Neptunes and them”. Management and their lawyers and all that stuff. She said that she didn’t initially notice that she was not getting paid properly for her work on her first two albums, both Neptunes produced, because she was making money from touring “and just the fact that I didn’t feel poor enough,” she says.

“Their argument is: ‘Well, you signed it,'” she continued. “I’m like: ‘Yeah, I signed what I said, and I was too young and too stupid to double-check it.'”

While she said she hadn’t seen Hugo until recently, she did see Farrell at an industry event a few years before the Guardian interview. “And he did to me the thing he’s infamous for, nodding off the stage [to someone in the audience], so it looks like there’s mutual respect, when in reality, I’m like, well, I’m not going to yell back: ‘You stole all my publications!’ So you finally nod and everyone thinks everything is great. Like, whatever.”

Williams — who talked about herself being on the wrong end of a publishing deal during her induction speech at the Songwriters Hall of Fame last month — has declined to discuss the situation with Kelis in the past and a representative for her. did not respond DiversityComment request. Hugo commented candidly on the issue during an interview with Vulture earlier this year, saying, “I heard about his feelings for her. I mean, I don’t handle it. I usually like that.” Hire business people to help with stuff. We had some great records with Kelis at the time.”

The macro issue – who should be credited and paid for a song, and how much – goes back to the early days of copyright, if not creativity itself. Diversity An article titled “Inside the Dirty Business of Hit Songwriting” explored the issue at length last year, indicating that the practice of artists or business people taking credit or royalties for songs not written by them in the 1950s decades and, as depicted in the movie 2020 “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom”, is much longer than that. While some examples are allegedly cut and dried—Elvis Presley’s manager and countless others have demanded a significant percentage of a song’s earnings, arguing that the money wouldn’t have worked without them—there are other gray areas. are among. More than 40 years after the song’s release, Procol Harum organizer Matthew Fischer won songwriting credits and retrospective royalties for the 1967 smash “A Whiter Shade of Pale” and argued countless other cases in and out of court. Gone. Williams lost herself in a songwriting trial in the high-profile “Blurred Lines” case in 2015, when a jury indicted her, Robin Thicke, and the song’s publisher, Marvin Gaye’s family, for the late singer’s 1977 violations. Ordered about $5 million. The hit “Got to Give It Up,” a decision that was upheld in 2018, although Williams says he disagrees.

Kelis has a dozen or so songwriting credits, including her 2006 hit “Bossy,” which has been certified double platinum in the US, however, in a Friday Instagram post she claims Williams has “never A Song Not Wrote, A Day in His Life” is exaggerated at best: with and without Hugo, Williams is one of the most successful songwriters and producers of the past 30 years, including her own “Happy Britney Spears”. I’m a Slave 4 U,” Beyonce. “Work It Out,” Snoop Dogg’s “Drop It While It’s Hot” and dozens of others.

who is right? Who is wrong? Only the people in the room know, and apparently the memories are different. The result of this situation, all of the above and countless others, is this: Make sure the credits and divisions are clear before the song is released, as “human civilization” will not last in court.

best of variety

Sign up for the Variety newsletter. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for the latest news.

Click here to read the full article.

Source link

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.